| Date | Matchup | Pick | Result | Running |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 23 | TEX @ LAA | LAA ML (+118) | W 5-2 | 21-27 (43.8%) |
| May 23 | STL @ CIN | STL ML (+119) | L 7-6 | 20-27 (42.6%) |
| May 22 | TB @ NYY | TB ML (+128) | W 2-4 | 20-26 (43.5%) |
| May 22 | CLE @ PHI | CLE ML (+153) | W 0-1 | 19-26 (42.2%) |
| May 22 | STL @ CIN | STL ML (+104) | W 1-8 | 18-26 (40.9%) |
| May 21 | ATL @ MIA | MIA ML (+114) | L 3-9 | 17-26 (39.5%) |
| May 21 | NYM @ WSH | WSH ML (-107) | L 1-2 | 17-25 (40.5%) |
| May 21 | COL @ AZ | COL ML (+169) | L 2-1 | 17-24 (41.5%) |
| May 21 | PIT @ STL | STL ML (+101) | L 2-6 | 17-23 (42.5%) |
| May 20 | CLE @ DET | DET ML (-105) | L 2-3 | 17-22 (43.6%) |
| May 20 | CIN @ PHI | CIN ML (+130) | W 4-9 | 17-21 (44.7%) |
| May 20 | TEX @ COL | COL ML (+104) | L 4-5 | 16-21 (43.2%) |
| May 20 | ATH @ LAA | LAA ML (+104) | L 5-6 | 16-20 (44.4%) |
| May 19 | HOU @ MIN | HOU ML (+115) | W 1-2 | 16-19 (45.7%) |
| May 19 | NYM @ WSH | WSH ML (+119) | W 9-6 | 15-19 (44.1%) |
| May 19 | LAD @ SD | SD ML (+139) | L 4-5 | 14-19 (42.4%) |
| May 19 | CLE @ DET | DET ML (+135) | L 3-4 | 14-18 (43.8%) |
| May 19 | ATL @ MIA | MIA ML (+118) | L 4-8 | 14-17 (45.2%) |
| May 19 | TOR @ NYY | TOR ML (+113) | L 5-4 | 14-16 (46.7%) |
| May 18 | ATH @ LAA | LAA ML (+107) | W 2-1 | 14-15 (48.3%) |